'I Don't Think I've Ever Heard This Response Before" - Alex O'Connor

In this episode, Alex O'Connor sits down with Rabbi David Wolpe for a probing conversation about God, religion, and belief. The discussion explores classic philosophical challenges to faith, including the problem of evil and how religious language is meant to be understood.

Rabbi Wolpe offers responses rooted in Jewish thought and tradition, pushing back on some of Alex's sharpest objections and offering perspectives that challenge conventional skeptical arguments. The exchange is marked by genuine curiosity on both sides, with Alex noting at points that he has never encountered certain arguments framed quite this way before.

The conversation touches on scripture, the nature of divine justice, and what it means to have faith in the face of uncertainty, making for a dense but accessible back-and-forth between a skeptic and a rabbi.

Key takeaways

• Alex O'Connor and Rabbi David Wolpe tackle long-standing philosophical objections to the existence of God
• Wolpe offers a distinctly Jewish theological perspective that surprises Alex with its novelty
• The problem of evil and divine justice are central themes of the discussion
• The conversation highlights the difference between philosophical and religious approaches to faith
• Both speakers engage respectfully despite fundamental disagreements about belief

Highlights

• 0:45 — Alex raises the problem of evil
• 2:30 — Rabbi Wolpe responds with a Jewish theological framing
• 5:10 — Discussion on how scripture should be interpreted
• 7:20 — Alex admits he's never heard this particular response before
• 9:40 — Closing reflections on faith and reason

00:00:00 Introduction To The Conversation
00:01:30 The Problem Of Evil
00:03:15 Defining God Philosophically
00:05:00 Interpreting Scripture And Tradition
00:06:45 A Novel Theological Response
00:08:30 Faith Versus Reason Debate
00:10:00 Closing Thoughts And Reflections

WEBVTT

00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:02.640
Getting<00:00:00.240> a<00:00:00.320> privacy<00:00:00.800> policy?<00:00:01.760> Great<00:00:02.000> move.

00:00:02.640 --> 00:00:05.160
Cookiebot<00:00:03.200> creates<00:00:03.560> yours<00:00:03.920> in<00:00:04.080> minutes<00:00:04.480> for<00:00:04.640> free.

00:00:05.160 --> 00:00:11.200
But<00:00:05.440> your<00:00:05.680> site<00:00:05.960> collects<00:00:06.320> visitor<00:00:06.720> data<00:00:07.000> via<00:00:07.200> cookies,<00:00:07.600> too,<00:00:08.120> which<00:00:08.440> requires<00:00:08.880> consent<00:00:09.560> and<00:00:09.800> a<00:00:09.880> cookie<00:00:10.160> policy.

00:00:11.200 --> 00:00:16.200
Cookiebot<00:00:11.760> handles<00:00:12.080> all<00:00:12.240> of<00:00:12.320> it.<00:00:12.880> Start<00:00:13.160> your<00:00:13.360> compliance<00:00:13.880> journey<00:00:14.200> today.